Why Your Peanut Butter Might Be at Risk: A Warning for New Yorkers

Whether you pack lunches for kids, enjoy peanut butter snacks yourself, or just like to stay in the know, this is a story you’ll want to read from start to finish. Over 20,000 peanut butter products have just been recalled, and yes, they’ve been distributed right here in New York.

A Major Recall Hits New York

Ventura Foods LLC first announced the recall last April after bits of blue plastic were found in a production filter. On February 12, the Food and Drug Administration upgraded it to a Class II recall, the second-highest risk level. In everyday terms, this means using the product could cause temporary or medically reversible health issues, but the odds of serious harm are low. Still, nobody expects to find plastic in their peanut butter.

READ MORE: What Every First-Time Home Buyer in New York Needs To Know

Types of Recalled Peanut Butter Packets

• Creamy peanut butter in 0.5 oz, 0.75 oz, and 1.12 oz packages
• Creamy peanut butter with grape jelly in 2.12 oz packages
• Creamy peanut butter with strawberry jam in 2.12 oz packages

Brands Impacted by the Recall

• Creamy Peanut Butter distributed by US Foods
• Peanut Butter and Flavor Fresh Peanut Butter distributed by DYMA Brands, Inc.
• House Recipe Creamy Peanut Butter distributed by Sysco Corporation
• Katy’s Kitchen Smooth Peanut Butter marketed by Independent Marketing Alliance
• Creamy Peanut Butter distributed exclusively by Gordon Food Service

You can find a full list of affected lot codes and details in the FDA’s official report.

Distribution in New York and Nearby States

These recalled products were distributed to 40 states, including New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Connecticut. So it’s worth double-checking your pantry, especially if you’ve picked up bulk or food-service style peanut butter packets.

How to Stay Safe

The FDA didn’t give detailed instructions for consumers, but with a Class II recall, the safest bet is clear: don’t eat it. If you’re not sure of the origin of your peanut butter, it’s probably best to toss it. It’s not worth the risk, especially if kids might grab them without a second thought.

Get our free mobile app

Why Peanut Butter Recalls Matter

Peanut butter is a staple that feels harmless and familiar. It’s in school lunches, office snack drawers, road trip coolers, and emergency food kits. That’s why recalls like this are important. Even if the risk of serious harm is low, knowing what’s in your food and staying alert helps protect you and your loved ones.