Some say that mountain lion sightings in New York and Pennsylvania are just as much folklore as bigfoot sightings. Others swear that mountain lions most certainly roam the rural woods of the Twin Tiers. So, who's right?

Get our free mobile app

In recent weeks, there have been several reported sightings of mountain lions in rural areas of the Twin Tiers. On Tuesday, September 28, the Choconut Inn in Friendsville, Pennsylvania jumped in on the conversation with a Facebook post that read, "Hi everyone there's been numerous mountain lion sightings by Quaker Lake. Please use caution. Especially at night."

The post by Choconut Inn garnered over 100 comments which ranged from those who swear they've seen the big cat with their own eyes to those who say it's more likely that what people have seen are just big bobcats. Obviously, people have a lot of opinions on whether or not mountain lions have found their way back to the Twin Tiers.

In 2011, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service unofficially deemed the eastern cougar (or mountain lion) extinct. Then, in 2018, it officially declared that the eastern version of the animal was in fact extinct.

While there is no argument that cougars (also called mountain lions) as a whole are very much still alive, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service claims that the version of the animal that was once located in the eastern part of the United States has actually been extinct for some 70 years.

What then are people actually seeing? Have bobcats grown in size and are they being confused for the massively large mountain lion? Or, have mountain lions from the west coast somehow managed to travel east into New York and Pennsylvania without detection? Even National Geographic refers to the Mountain Lion as the "Bigfoot of Big Cats" because it is so elusive and mystical, even.

In 2011, a male mountain lion was found to have traveled nearly 2,000 miles from "South Dakota through Minnesota, Wisconsin and New York, and was killed on a Connecticut highway. A cougar of unknown origin was also killed in Kentucky in December 2014," according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

It isn't completely out of the realm of possibility that a rogue mountain lion from the west coast could have found its way into the Twin Tiers and that is what residents of the Brackney, Pennsylvania area have seen.

A 2016 study conducted by wildlife experts claimed that reintroducing mountain lions to the Northeast would reduce white-tailed deer density which in turn would reduce deer/vehicle collisions by 22 percent, preventing "21,400 human injuries, 155 fatalities, and $2.13 billion in preventive costs within just 30 years of reintroduction.'

The same study also took a look at which states would be most habitable for mountain lions and those states were New Hampshire, West Virginia, Vermont, Maine, Massachusetts, Connecticut, New York, and Pennsylvania. 

Still, questions remain. Have mountain lions been migrating from the west to the east? Has the government been slowly and stealthy reintroducing the animal to the Northeast? Or, has the average bobcat just grown so large that people are confused about what they're seeing?

It might be years before any solid answers are provided which means the folklore and debates about mountain lion sightings in the Twin Tiers of New York and Pennsylvania will most certainly rage on.

SOUTH OF THE BORDER: 32 Things that Make Northeast Pennsylvania 'NEPa'

 

35 Awesome Southern Tier & Northern PA Town Welcome Signs

LOOK: Here are the pets banned in each state

Because the regulation of exotic animals is left to states, some organizations, including The Humane Society of the United States, advocate for federal, standardized legislation that would ban owning large cats, bears, primates, and large poisonous snakes as pets.

Read on to see which pets are banned in your home state, as well as across the nation.

LOOK: Stunning animal photos from around the world

From grazing Tibetan antelope to migrating monarch butterflies, these 50 photos of wildlife around the world capture the staggering grace of the animal kingdom. The forthcoming gallery runs sequentially from air to land to water, and focuses on birds, land mammals, aquatic life, and insects as they work in pairs or groups, or sometimes all on their own.

LOOK: 30 fascinating facts about sleep in the animal kingdom